Nearly 150,000 bicycles were reported stolen across America in 2023, according to FBI crime data released September 23rd, 2024, with losses totaling over $148 million. But that's just what gets reported - studies suggest the true number could exceed half a million thefts annually when unreported incidents are included.
Welcome to the great American bike heist, starring five theft hotspots that account for more than 54,000 reported thefts - over one-third of all bicycle crimes nationwide: California, Colorado, Florida, New York and Texas.
California and Texas lead on pure volume; New York and Florida blend dense cities with tourism; and Colorado punches way above its weight on a per-capita basis. Together they represent the full spectrum of theft scenarios, from ferry-terminal strip-downs to trail-head smash-and-grabs.
California and Texas win on raw tonnage of stolen bikes
New York and Florida add tourist churn, urban density, and no shortage of creative getaway routes.
Colorado punches unusually high above its population weight with the highest per-capita theft rates.
California's numbers dwarf every other state, accounting for more than 14% of all reported bike thefts nationally. Despite the massive totals, the state's per capita rate of 54.1 thefts per 100,000 residents reflects its enormous population. Under-reporting means this could translate to over 300,000 actual thefts when the "dark number" is factored in. Premium road bikes and e-bikes are prime targets, with thieves operating from San Francisco's ferry terminals to Los Angeles parking structures.
The state's bike-friendly culture creates both opportunity and vulnerability. High-value bikes are everywhere, but so are the thieves who know how to spot them.
With 38.5 thefts per 100,000 residents, Texas sits in the middle of the pack for per capita rates despite its massive theft totals. SXSW turns bike racks into opportunities, while Hill Country destinations see tailgate-pad extractions.
The $896 average value reflects everything from daily commuters to weekend warriors falling victim across the state's diverse cycling scenes.
Colorado leads the nation with 124.8 thefts per 100,000 residents - more than four times higher than Florida's rate and over twice California's. The $1,937 average stolen bike value is the highest in America, reflecting Colorado's premium mountain bike culture. Tailgate-pad raids are happening at trailheads across the state, with thieves targeting high-end full-suspension rigs.
The combination of outdoor recreation culture, high-value bike concentration, and tourist areas with limited security creates a perfect storm for theft. When factoring in unreported incidents, Colorado could be seeing over 100,000 actual bike thefts annually.
At 29.1 thefts per 100,000 residents, Florida has the lowest per capita rate among major states despite significant total numbers. Spring break creates prime conditions for bike theft, with everything from beach cruisers to serious road bikes disappearing from hotel racks and condo garages. The $725 average value reflects the range from rental bikes to enthusiast rides, with tourist areas seeing seasonal spikes in theft activity.
Higher recovery rates suggest better community vigilance in Florida's cycling communities.
With 30.8 thefts per 100,000 residents, New York's per capita rate remains relatively modest despite urban density. The 6,166 reports could hide around 98,000 actual thefts when unreported incidents are factored in. The dense urban environment creates both vulnerability and opportunity, with delivery cyclists and commuters facing constant threats. The $915 average value reflects the urban cycling economy, from delivery e-bikes to commuter road bikes.
Close-knit urban communities create opportunities for recovery through community reporting and police involvement.
Analysis of 3,299 recovered bike reports reveals the real pathways back to owners - and it's not always the methods you'd expect in America's ongoing two-wheeled heist saga.
The numbers tell a fascinating story: old-school policing and modern digital sleuthing are neck-and-neck, together accounting for over half of all recoveries. What's particularly striking is how the game has evolved - AirTags are leading cops to entire theft rings, while Facebook Marketplace has become both a thief's storefront and an owner's hunting ground.
Many successful recoveries involve multiple methods working together. A bike spotted on Craigslist triggers police involvement, or community members recognize a ride from social media posts. This tag-team approach suggests that effective bike security requires both individual prep work (registration, tracking devices) and community muscle (marketplace monitoring, neighborhood watch networks).
"...one of our recent success stories came from Winnipeg, where a cyclist had both registered their ebike with the 529 Garage and installed a tracker. When their bike was stolen, they were able to use the information from tracker to help the police locate the bike, and because the bike was properly registered with photos, the officer could quickly verify ownership and recover it. This is exactly why we partnered with Bikebac - when you combine community vigilance, proper registration, and tracking technology, you create a powerful recovery system that actually works."
- Rob Brunt, 529 bike detective
The surprisingly high success rate of owner-led detective work shows that motivated bike-theft victims, armed with the right tools and community backup, can be remarkably effective investigators. But the data also confirms that formal systems - police databases, bike shop networks, and organized community groups - remain the backbone of the recovery game.
The bottom line? Your best shot at reunion with a stolen bike comes from stacking the deck: proper registration, active community engagement, and maybe a well-hidden AirTag for good measure.
"Stats in Canada says for every 10 people that have their bike stolen, one person disengages and never rides again. So we can build this huge infrastructure, but if we don't take care of the crime of theft of bicycles, we're losing riders." - Vancouver Police Detective Rob Brunt explains the hidden cost of bike theft in this interview with Tom Babin from Shifter, a channel dedicated to urban cycling and bike commuting solutions.
The scale of bike theft is staggering and growing. When someone's bike gets stolen, many don't replace it immediately - or at all. Beyond prevention, recovery plays a significant role. New data from Project 529's stolen bike database (2023 to June 2025) shows bikes with identification shields have a 23.1% recovery rate compared to just 7.6% for unprotected bikes. In the US specifically the overall rate decreases to 15.1% compared to 4.8%. That's a 3x difference that could mean the difference between replacing a $2,000 bike or simply filing a police report.
Standard homeowner policies often leave cyclists exposed with sporting goods caps of $1,000- $2,500, high deductibles that consume most payouts, and premium increases after claims. Many policies also exclude bikes stolen from vehicles or during events. Learn more about homeowners vs. specialized bicycle insurance.
Specialized bike insurance addresses these gaps with full replacement value coverage, lower deductibles ($100-$250 typical), coverage during transport and racing, and no impact on home insurance rates.
The dark number multiplier: Whatever the state reports, reality could be 15 times worse due to under-reporting.
Registration works: Project 529 data shows clear recovery rate improvements with proper bike identification.
"Registration helps the bike owner have the information they need in the palm of their hands, and police are able to quickly find the owners of bikes that they recover. 529 Garage also gives the community and bike shops a way to check bikes before they are purchased. And in fact, we often see recoveries from tips from groups that patrol online marketplaces in an effort to fight the problem."
- Rob Brunt, 529 bike detective
Community vigilance pays: Half of all bike recoveries involve police work or online marketplace detection by fellow cyclists.
Lock like you mean it. Frame + rear wheel U-locked; front chained; consider a moat. See our ultimate guide to locking your bicycle.
Register the serial. Project 529, Project 529's database searches over 3 million bikes including our registrations plus partner data from Bike Index and bike shops - increasing your chance of recovery if your bicycle is stolen.
Don’t just lock it. Insure it. Even a heavy-duty lock is just a gentle suggestion to anyone with a cordless grinder. Sundays Insurance patches the crater in your bank account.
Bike theft isn't inevitable, and recovery isn't just luck. The FBI data shows clear patterns by state, while Project 529 data reveals what actually works for getting bikes back.
Whether you're facing Colorado's extreme per-capita risk or California's high-volume theft environment, the solution involves registration, proper insurance, and community vigilance. Because in America's bike theft crisis, preparation isn't paranoia - it's just smart cycling.
Homeowner policies often treat your pride-and-joy like a rusty rake. Sundays treats it like a life-support machine keeping you sane in America's rolling grand theft bicycle.
At Sundays Insurance, we believe that reducing bike theft isn't just about protecting individual bikes - it's about protecting the future of cycling itself. When people feel secure about their investment, they're more likely to choose two wheels over four. That's why we're committed to both comprehensive coverage and supporting theft prevention initiatives that keep more riders on the road.
join.cc — Bike theft by state: Latest FBI data analyzed
cde.ucr.cjis.gov — Crime Data Explorer (CDE)
Yannick Read has spent more than two decades at the coalface of cycling, championing riders’ rights for national advocacy bodies and popping up when the media needs a voice on two wheels -whether that’s Discovery Channel documentaries, NBC news slots or Jeremy Clarkson’s The Grand Tour. When he’s not talking about bikes, he’s usually building something barely recognisable’ one of his creations holds two Guinness World Records (the 136 dB “Hornster” for world’s loudest bicycle horn, and the world’s smallest road-legal bicycle caravan).
Subscribe to our newsletter for coverage tips, community stories, and enriching cycling experiences delivered straight to your inbox.
